Close X

FICO VS. VANTAGESCORE CREDIT SCORES

Posted by Ryan D. Peterson | Oct 25, 2021 | 0 Comments

The credit score you find online probably isn't the same number the auto lender sees when you apply to finance a new vehicle. It isn't the same as the score a mortgage lender or credit card issuer might see either. In fact, a credit score check in each of these situations might come back with significantly different results. FICO or VantageScore credit score?

credit score you find online may differ from the score a lender uses for several reasons. First, three different credit bureaus (EquifaxTransUnion and Experian) maintain your credit reports. So, if you check a credit score based on your Equifax credit report but a lender checks a score based on your TransUnion report, the numbers won't match. Another contributing factor is the fact that there's more than one credit score band.

You might also like: Your Money, Your Future – Video

In the U.S., most credit scores are created either by FICO or VantageScore Solutions. And while there are many similarities in how FICO Scores and VantageScore credit scores work, there are some noteworthy differences too.

Similarities Between FICO Scores and VantageScore

credit score is a snapshot evaluation of your credit risk at a given point in time. It can help lenders judge whether loaning you money is a wise investment. Since both FICO and VantageScore credit scores serve this same purpose, it shouldn't be surprising that they share a number of features.

You might also likePhony Debt Collection Scams

Credit Score Range

FICO Scores range from 300 to 850. At first, VantageScore credit scores featured a different numerical scale (501 to 990). However, VantageScore 3.0 and 4.0 adopted the same 300 to 850 scale that FICO uses.

With both FICO and VantageScore models, higher scores are better. Higher scores make it easier to qualify for financing and to receive competitive financing offers from lenders. In fact, the lifetime value of a good credit score could save you tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Design Objective

Credit score creators design their scoring models to do a specific job. This job is known as the scoring model's stated design objective. Both FICO and VantageScore credit scores share the same stated design objective. They can predict the likelihood that a consumer will pay any credit obligation 90 days late or worse within the two years.

When you have a higher credit score it means you're less likely to pay your bills severely late (90 days or more after the due date) in the near future (the next 24 months). A lower credit score signals the opposite.

Credit Score Factors

Your credit scores, regardless of the brand, are influenced by similar factors. These details include information like your payment history, credit utilization ratio, the age of your accounts, a mixture of account types, and more.

All of the factors which cause your credit score to move up or down are found on your credit reports. Information outside of your credit reports has no direct impact on your scores. This fact is true whether those numbers are calculated by a FICO or a VantageScore credit scoring model.

Photo by CardMapr on Unsplash Difference between FICO Score and VantageScore

ECOA Compliance

Before a lender can use a credit score to evaluate applicants, the scoring model must pass a few tests. Specifically, it has to satisfy a federal law known as the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA).

The ECOA states that credit scores used for lending purposes in the U.S. must be empirically derived, demonstrably and statistically sound. Those terms mean that credit scores in the U.S. need to be built using a proven, scientific method (aka empirically derived). And they have to work (aka demonstrably and statistically sound).

credit score is supposed to predict the likelihood that someone will pay a bill 90 or more days late in the upcoming 24 months. So, FICO and VantageScore Solutions have to prove that each credit scoring model they build does what it's designed to do.

Differences Between FICO Scores and VantageScore

Despite the fact that FICO Scores and VantageScores serve a similar purpose, they aren't identical. You can think of them like the Pepsi and Coca Cola of the financial world. Below are a few key differences between the two credit score brands.

Founders

FICO and VantageScore Solutions are two competing companies. Each one creates and sells credit scores to lenders and other businesses in the financial industry.

FICO is a publicly-traded company based in California. The analytics company was founded in 1956 by an engineer, Bill Fair, and a mathematician, Earl Isaac. VantageScore Solutions, based in Connecticut, was jointly founded by EquifaxTransUnion and Experian in 2006.

Minimum Scoring Criteria

Not everyone is eligible for a credit score. In order to receive one, your credit report must first satisfy a scoring models' minimum criteria.

To qualify a FICO Score, your credit report needs to display a tradeline (e.g., credit card, loan, line of credit, etc.) that's a minimum of six months old. And at least one tradeline on your report must show some activity in the last six months.

Qualifying for a VantageScore is a little easier. Your credit report simply needs at least one tradeline present, regardless of the age of that account.

If you don't have a credit card, other types of payments may qualify. A service like Experian Boost may help ensure you have every opportunity to build a credit profile.

You might also like: Have You Been Sued by Midland Credit?

Points Value

credit scoring model looks over your credit report and awards you a certain number of points based on the information it finds. You can earn points for each factor the scoring model considers (e.g., payment history, credit utilization, length of credit history, credit inquiries, etc.). For example, a credit report with zero late payments would be worth X number of points to be added to your overall score.

FICO and VantageScore models assign different values (or weights) to the items they find on your credit report. Your delinquency-free credit report might earn you 150 points toward your FICO Score. But that same report with no late payments might net you 155 points under a VantageScore scoring model. These point values are purely hypothetical, but they do reflect the way credit scores work.

Credit Score Values

As mentioned, FICO Scores and VantageScore credit scores share the same range of 300 to 850. Higher scores indicate less risk. But the way lenders interpret the two types of scores may not be identical.

The definition of a good credit score can vary from lender to lender. It may also differ based on the credit score brand. For example, a 670 FICO Score might be high enough to qualify for a credit card with ABC Bank. But you might need a 680 VantageScore credit score for a different credit card issuer to approve your application.

The chart below is a general guide to show how your FICO Score or VantageScore credit score might rank.

FICO/VantageScore Rating FICO Score Range VantageScore Range
Exceptional/Excellent 800-850 781-850
Very Good/Good 740-799 661-780
Good/Fair 670-739 601-660
Fair/Poor 580-669 500-600
Poor/Very Poor 300-579 300-499

Do You Know Your Score?

What You Need to Know

After reading the information above, it should now be clear that you don't have just one credit score. You have many. Between the many different FICO and VantageScore versions, there are actually hundreds of different credit scores that lenders may use to evaluate you—thousands if you count custom-made models.

When you learn that there are so many different credit score possibilities, it's natural to have a few questions.

Article courtesy of Forbes, by Michelle Black, Dia Adams

About the Author

Ryan D. Peterson

Attorney Ryan D. Peterson Ryan D. Peterson is a former debt collection attorney turned consumer rights expert and advocate. After graduating from William Mitchell law school in 2008, Ryan opened his own criminal defense firm. In 2010 Ryan joined a Minneapolis-based debt collection firm. Ther...

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Peterson Legal, PLLC Is Here for You

At Peterson Legal, we focus on Collection Agency Defense, Credit Report Errors, Debt Collection Harassment, Identity Theft, and Student Loan Collections and we are here to listen to you and help you navigate the legal system.

Contact Us Today

Peterson Legal is committed to answering your questions about Collection Agency Defense, Credit Report Errors, Debt Collection Harassment, Identity Theft, and Student Loan Collections issues in Minnesota.

We offer a Free Consultation and we'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.